Endurance and ASE Protection Warranty are two major extended car warranty providers with distinct differences in coverage, service, and benefits. Here's a detailed comparison to help you make an informed decision.

Coverage Options

Endurance:

• 7 comprehensive plans including Supreme, Supreme for Highline Vehicles, Superior, Select Premier, Secure Plus, Secure, and Advantage
• Covers specialty vehicles (Canadian Gray Market, rebuilt/salvage titles, commercial use)
• Offers mechanical breakdown insurance in California
• 30-day money-back guarantee
• Customizable coverage options

ASE Protection Warranty:

• 3 basic plans: Blue Shield, Blue Shield PLUS, and Total Blue Shield
• Basic component coverage varying by tier
• Limited customization options

Customer Service Experience

Endurance:

• High Trustpilot rating with 9,000+ reviews
• A- BBB rating
• Award-winning customer service team
• Responsive claim handling
• 24/7 mobile app access

ASE Protection Warranty:

• 1.8/5 Trustpilot rating
• F rating from BBB
• Limited customer service responsiveness
• Multiple complaints about payment issues

Claims Process

Endurance:

• Simple, streamlined process
• Direct communication between repair shop and Endurance
• Customer only pays deductible
• Available through any certified repair shop

ASE Protection Warranty:

• Customer must mediate between shop and company
• Requires more involvement from customer
• Available at ASE-certified shops only

Additional Benefits

Endurance:

• 24/7 roadside assistance
• Rental car coverage
• Trip interruption coverage
• Elite Benefits package including tire repair/replacement, key fob replacement, and total loss protection
• Comprehensive mobile app

ASE Protection Warranty:

• Courtesy towing only
• No additional perks or benefits

Verdict: Endurance offers more comprehensive coverage options, better customer service, and additional benefits, making it the stronger choice for most drivers seeking extended vehicle protection.

Related Articles

Previous Articles